Chapter 1 · Lesson 2 of 6 · about 14 minutes
Where you fly sets the mix
The three populations are not spread evenly. The geomagnetic field holds the trapped particles in belts and, at the same time, shields low-inclination, low-altitude orbits from most solar and galactic particles. Move the same hardware from the ISS orbit to a sun-synchronous orbit, to a navigation orbit or to GEO and the dominant population changes, often by orders of magnitude. The orbit is therefore part of the radiation requirement, and the requirement has to state it.
What you need to know
Two properties of the geomagnetic field organize the environment.
Trapping. The field holds protons and electrons on shells labeled by the McIlwain parameter L, the equatorial distance of the shell in Earth radii. The inner proton zone lies below about L = 2; the outer electron zone peaks near L = 4 to 5. Because the dipole is offset and tilted, the inner zone reaches lowest altitude over the South Atlantic. A 400 km orbit at 51.6° meets trapped protons only on the passes that cross that region. An 800 km polar orbit meets them there and also meets the outer-zone electrons at high latitude on every pass. A navigation orbit at 20,200 km lies in the heart of the outer zone and above the inner-zone protons, and GEO lies at the outer edge of the electron belt.
Cutoff. The same field deflects charged particles arriving from outside. Whether a particle reaches a given point depends on its rigidity (momentum per unit charge) and on the magnetic latitude. Near the equator at low altitude only particles above roughly 10 to 15 GV get through, while over the polar caps almost everything does. Solar protons are mostly below 1 GV, so a low-inclination orbit is nearly closed to them, a polar orbit is open over the caps, and GEO and interplanetary space are fully exposed. Galactic cosmic rays extend to much higher rigidity, so the cutoff removes only their low-energy part. Those low-energy ions are the ones with the highest LET, so the LET spectrum at low inclination falls far below the free-space spectrum at the iron knee.
| Orbit | Trapped protons | Trapped electrons | Solar protons | Galactic cosmic rays |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ISS, 400 km, 51.6° | South Atlantic Anomaly passes | Weak, high-latitude passes | Nearly excluded in quiet conditions | About a quarter of free space (iron) |
| Sun-synchronous, 800 km, 98.6° | Anomaly passes, ten times the ISS flux | Outer-zone horns on every pass | Polar caps open: about a fifth of free space | Under half of free space |
| Navigation, 20,200 km, 55° | None above a few MeV | Heart of the outer zone | About two thirds of free space | Nearly full |
| GEO, 35,786 km | None | Outer edge of the belt, strongly variable | Full, less the Earth shadow | Full |
Pick an environment and a threshold; the readout gives the omnidirectional flux above that LET and how often an ion above it crosses a die of the area you enter.
Worked example: the same box in four orbits
The question. The box from lesson 1 is proposed for three other missions. What changes?
Inputs. The same SPENVIS runs as lesson 1 for four orbits (AP-8 MIN, ISO 15390 at solar minimum with quiet cutoff, ESP-PSYCHIC 95 % for one active year), the CREME96 LET spectra behind 100 mil of aluminum from the Space-RHA SEE tool, and the one-year trapped doses behind 100 mil of aluminum from the Space-RHA hardware panel (AE-8 MAX and AP-8 MAX, SHIELDOSE-2, center of a solid aluminum sphere). The sun-synchronous LET case is published at 600 km and 97.8°, the closest available to the 800 km orbit of the particle runs.
| Quantity (per cm² unless stated) | ISS 400 km, 51.6° | SSO 800 km, 98.6° | Nav 20,200 km, 55° | GEO |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trapped protons above 10 MeV, per s (AP-8 MIN) | 17.6 | 168 | none above 6 MeV | none |
| GCR iron above 100 MeV/n, per m² sr s (ISO 15390) | 0.210 | 0.368 | 0.852 | 0.865 |
| Solar protons above 10 MeV, one active year, 95 % | 6.5 × 10⁶ | 7.6 × 10⁹ | 2.3 × 10¹⁰ | 3.6 × 10¹⁰ |
| Geomagnetic transmission of those protons | 1 × 10⁻⁴ | 0.21 | 0.65 | 0.994 |
| GCR ions above LET 10, per day, 100 mil Al | 0.029 | 0.206 (600 km) | 0.80 | 0.92 |
| GCR ions above LET 30, per day, 100 mil Al | 1.3 × 10⁻⁵ | 8.4 × 10⁻⁵ (600 km) | 3.4 × 10⁻⁴ | 3.6 × 10⁻⁴ |
| Trapped dose per year, rad(Si), 100 mil Al | 381 (420 km) | 2,580 | not run | 88,300 |
Steps.
- Read the trapped-proton column. Moving from 400 km to 800 km raises the flux above 10 MeV by a factor of 9.5. Above 20,000 km AP-8 has no protons above 6 MeV. Proton displacement damage and proton SEE are mainly a low-orbit problem.
- Read the solar-proton row with its transmission. The free-space fluence is the same in all four cases; the orbit decides the share that arrives. The ISS orbit receives one part in ten thousand, the polar orbit about a fifth, the navigation orbit about two thirds, GEO nearly all. For the polar orbit that fifth is still 7.6 × 10⁹ protons per cm² above 10 MeV in a bad year, more than the trapped-proton fluence of the same year (lesson 4).
- Read the LET rows. Above LET 1 the free-space flux is 6 times the ISS value, above LET 10 it is 32 times, and above LET 30 about 27 times. The cutoff removes the low-rigidity ions first, which is why the ratio rises steeply between LET 1 and LET 10; above the iron knee it levels off, because behind 100 mil of aluminum the ions that still have such a high LET are the ones that arrived with enough energy to pass the cutoff and were slowed in the shield. A part with a measured LET threshold of 30 MeV·cm²/mg sees roughly one crossing per cm² every 200 years at the ISS orbit and one every 8 years in free space (lesson 5 makes this calculation).
- Read the dose row. Behind 100 mil of aluminum the polar orbit accumulates about 7 times the ISS dose per year and GEO about 34 times the polar value, almost all of it from electrons. These are model outputs for a solid sphere; a real box with its own geometry generally differs (lesson 5).
Result. The same box has a different dominant problem in each orbit.
- ISS orbit: anomaly protons and a modest dose.
- Polar orbit: protons, electrons and a yearly solar-proton exposure.
- 20,200 km: electrons, near-full cosmic rays and solar protons.
- GEO: electron dose of order 10⁵ rad per year and the full heavy-ion spectrum.
Each of those calls for a different emphasis in the parts list and in the test plan, and none of them is implied by the word "LEO" or "GEO" alone.
Going deeper
The vertical cutoff rigidity
For a centered dipole the vertical cutoff rigidity at magnetic latitude λ and radial distance r is R_c ≈ 14.9 cos⁴λ / (r/R_E)² GV (Størmer theory, with the 14.9 GV constant from the dipole moment of the present epoch; the value drifts slowly as the moment decays). At 400 km and the magnetic equator this gives about 13 GV, which stops every solar proton and all galactic protons below roughly 12 GeV (about 6 GeV per nucleon for heavier nuclei, whose charge-to-mass ratio is half); at 60° magnetic latitude it falls to about 0.8 GV. Real cutoffs differ from this expression because the field is not a dipole, because particles arrive from all directions (the east-west effect), and because storms depress the cutoff by a few degrees of latitude (the SPENVIS stormy-magnetosphere option represents this). Trajectory-traced cutoff maps in a modern field model are the standard for a project. The dipole formula is for orientation. Smart and Shea (2005) review the methods.
Why the South Atlantic Anomaly is where it is
The geomagnetic dipole axis is tilted about 11° from the rotation axis and its center is displaced several hundred kilometers from the Earth's center toward the western Pacific. On the opposite side, over the South Atlantic, a given field strength is reached at lower altitude, so the inner zone dips to altitudes that low Earth orbits cross. The anomaly drifts westward by a fraction of a degree per year and its area grows as the dipole moment decays, so the AP-8 maps, built on 1960s and 1970s data with the field epochs of that time, place it east of its present position. SPENVIS and other implementations handle this by evaluating the model in the field epoch it was built with and mapping the orbit into that frame.
What the four orbits look like in the 3D view
The site's environment view draws each of these orbits in the belt geometry, with the particle populations the orbit actually meets. The ISS, sun-synchronous and navigation orbits can be opened directly: ISS, sun-synchronous, navigation orbit. The view shows where the trapped protons appear along the track and where the solar protons gain access during an event.
The common mistake
The common mistake is to specify an orbit regime ("LEO") without the inclination, altitude and epoch. Within LEO alone the numbers in the table change by a factor of ten in trapped protons and a factor of two thousand in solar protons between 51.6° and 98.6°. A second mistake is to read the geomagnetic transmission as a safety factor. It applies to quiet conditions and depends on energy, and the stormy case in lesson 1 was four times larger.
Takeaway
Altitude sets the trapped-particle exposure, inclination sets the access of solar and galactic particles, and together they decide which population dominates. The requirement has to state both.
Check yourself
A supplier offers heavy-ion test data showing no events to LET 30 MeV·cm²/mg and argues the part is immune for a sun-synchronous mission. What else do you need to know?
The fluence reached without events, the ion energies and ranges, the incidence angle, the bias and operating conditions, and whether the part is in a function that solar heavy ions could reach during an event. No events to LET 30 at a stated fluence bounds the galactic rate (lesson 5). It does not bound the rate during a large solar event, and it says nothing about proton-induced effects from the anomaly protons, which the sun-synchronous orbit meets at ten times the ISS flux.
A proposal states its orbit as "LEO, about 600 km" and asks for an environment. A colleague suggests taking the trapped-proton flux from the ISS run and scaling it later. What is missing, and how much can it matter?
The inclination, the exact altitude and the epoch. Within LEO alone the table changes by a factor of ten in trapped protons above 10 MeV (17.6 to 168 cm⁻² s⁻¹ between 400 km at 51.6° and 800 km at 98.6°) and by a factor of two thousand in the one-year solar-proton fluence (6.5 × 10⁶ to 7.6 × 10⁹ per cm²), and the galactic flux above LET 10 behind 100 mil rises from 0.029 to 0.206 per cm² per day (the 600 km case). Altitude sets the trapped exposure and inclination sets the access of solar and galactic particles, so a scaling applied later would have to reproduce both, and the sheet generally cannot be filled until the orbit is stated.
The sheet gives a geomagnetic transmission of 0.21 for solar protons above 10 MeV on the 800 km polar orbit. A designer applies it to the whole solar spectrum and to the design event, and books the reduction as margin. What is wrong with that?
The transmission is a quiet-condition model result that depends on energy, since the cutoff acts on rigidity and higher-energy protons pass more readily, so one number above 10 MeV does not describe the spectrum. Storms depress the cutoff by a few degrees of latitude, and at the ISS orbit the stormy case of lesson 1 was four times the quiet one. The reduction is therefore a property of the environment case, to be stated with the case, and not a safety factor that can be set against model error or part variability (lesson 6).
The ISS orbit sees about a quarter of the free-space galactic iron above 100 MeV/n (0.210 against 0.865 per m² per sr per s). A team proposes dividing a GEO heavy-ion upset rate by four to get the ISS rate. Why is that generally not right?
The cutoff removes the low-rigidity ions first, and those low-energy ions carry the highest LET, so the reduction at a given LET threshold is larger than the reduction in the count of iron above an energy. Behind 100 mil of aluminum the flux above LET 10 is 0.029 per cm² per day at the ISS orbit against 0.92 in free space, a factor of 32, and above LET 30 it is 1.3 × 10⁻⁵ against 3.6 × 10⁻⁴, a factor of 27. The ratio changes with LET, so the rate has to be recomputed from the orbit's own LET spectrum folded with the device cross section (lesson 5 and chapter 3) rather than scaled from another orbit.
A proton-sensitive part passed review for the ISS orbit on the basis of the anomaly protons. It is now proposed for the 20,200 km navigation orbit, where AP-8 has no protons above 6 MeV, and a colleague says the proton analysis can be dropped. What is missing?
The solar protons. The navigation orbit receives about two thirds of the free-space solar-proton fluence (transmission 0.65), which is 2.3 × 10¹⁰ per cm² above 10 MeV in a 95 % active year against 6.5 × 10⁶ at the ISS orbit. Trapped-proton displacement damage and proton SEE are mainly a low-orbit problem, but proton effects in general are not: above the inner zone they are set by solar events, so the requirement moves from an anomaly-pass rate to a design-event rate and a cumulative active-year fluence (lessons 3 and 4).
Further reading
- S. Bourdarie and M. Xapsos, "The near-Earth space radiation environment," IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 55, no. 4, pp. 1810-1832, 2008. NTRS 20080039622.
- D. F. Smart and M. A. Shea, "A review of geomagnetic cutoff rigidities for earth-orbiting spacecraft," Adv. Space Res., vol. 36, no. 10, pp. 2012-2020, 2005.
- G. P. Ginet et al., "AE9, AP9 and SPM: new models for specifying the trapped energetic particle and space plasma environment," Space Sci. Rev., vol. 179, pp. 579-615, 2013.
- W. R. Johnston et al., "Recent updates to the AE9/AP9/SPM radiation belt and space plasma specification model," IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 62, no. 6, pp. 2760-2766, 2015. doi:10.1109/TNS.2015.2476470.
- A. J. Tylka et al., "CREME96: a revision of the Cosmic Ray Effects on Micro-Electronics code," IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 2150-2160, 1997.
- Space-RHA, "SEE rate tool," space-rha.com/see-tool.html (the CREME96 LET spectra used here).
- Space-RHA, "Space radiation environment in 3D," space-rha.com/space-radiation-environment (the hardware panel supplies the dose figures used here).