Chapter 2 · Lesson 3 of 6 · about 10 minutes
What a shield does to each particle
A shield can stop or slow particles, but it also scatters them and creates secondary radiation. Removing the lower-energy particles often brings the accumulated dose down. The particles that get through can still cause single-event effects, so shielding and device robustness have to work together.
Particles change inside a shield
The same calculator as chapter 1, with the material choice in front: aluminum, polyethylene, tantalum or a graded stack, at the areal density you set.
Accumulated dose
Shielding often reduces TID substantially at first. As more material is added, the gain from each layer generally shrinks, because what remains is the more penetrating part of the spectrum. How quickly that happens depends on the spectrum, the materials and the target.
Single-event effects
A shield removes some of the particles that matter for SEE and changes others. High-energy ions get through, and nuclear reactions in the shield create secondaries, so a practical amount of shielding cannot take the place of suitable parts and system mitigation.
Interactions by particle
Electrons, protons, heavy ions, photons and neutrons each interact with a shield in their own way, so the trade has to be made for the particles that dominate the problem.
Material, spectrum and mass budget
Low-Z and high-Z materials stop, scatter and produce secondaries differently. Compare them at equal thickness and at equal mass as two separate comparisons, because a volume limit and a mass limit lead to different choices. Which material is the better choice depends on the incident spectrum, the volume available, the order of the layers and the quantity scored at the target.
Electron dominated. High-Z material can stop electrons in a short distance and scatter them strongly, but it also produces more bremsstrahlung. A low-Z layer on the entry side can reduce that photon source, and a high-Z layer can then absorb the photons that are produced. A good mixed stack depends on the spectrum, the geometry and the target; there is no one ordering that is right for every case.
Proton dominated. Under a mass limit, low-Z and hydrogen-rich materials can be attractive. A dense high-Z material saves volume, but that does not make it better protection per kilogram. Compare the residual proton energies behind each candidate and the nuclear secondaries that matter, including those made in the package material next to the die.
Hard-electron exception. Santin 2022 §3.6 explains that a hard Jovian electron spectrum can favor a high-Z fraction in the stack when the penetrating primaries dominate the dose. The best stack still depends on the spectrum, the target and the constraint.
Source distinctions. Many trapped-electron TID cases benefit strongly from shielding. For trapped protons and solar particles the benefit depends on the spectrum. GCR and their fragments are penetrating, and they are harder to control within a typical spacecraft mass budget. The name of the source alone does not tell you how much a shield will help, for dose or for SEE.
Two different constraints. Changing the wall thickness changes the enclosure mass and every ray path through it. A sketch of a layered stack and its order illustrates the interactions; it is not a computed two-layer attenuation. One mm and one g/cm² are different constraints, one on volume and one on mass, and a comparison has to say which one it holds fixed.
Worked example: four shield materials at the same areal density
The question. On the 800 km polar orbit of chapter 1, a box wall is allowed a fixed mass per unit area. Does the choice of material change the dose behind it?
Inputs. The Space-RHA hardware panel: one year of AE-8 MAX electrons and AP-8 MAX protons, SHIELDOSE-2 for aluminum, Monte Carlo electron kernels for polyethylene, tantalum and a graded aluminum-tantalum-aluminum stack with half the mass in each metal, and proton range equivalence for the non-aluminum shields.
| Areal density | Electrons + brems., Al | Polyethylene | Tantalum | Graded Al/Ta/Al | Trapped protons, Al / PE / Ta |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.5 g/cm² | 3,994 | 3,593 | 1,386 | 2,128 | 524 / 447 / 734 |
| 1 g/cm² | 779 | 620 | 212 | 338 | 407 / 345 / 500 |
| 2 g/cm² | 30 | 46 | 37 | 10 | 306 / 267 / 376 |
| 3 g/cm² | 6 | 10 | 8 | 2 | 262 / 232 / 319 |
Steps.
- Read across the electron columns at 1 g/cm². Tantalum gives about 0.27 of the aluminum electron dose and the graded stack about 0.43; polyethylene gives about 0.80. The high-Z metal scatters and stops electrons in less mass.
- Read the same columns at 3 g/cm², where only bremsstrahlung is left of the electron dose. Tantalum is now 1.4 times aluminum: it generates more X rays than it absorbs. The graded stack, which absorbs its own bremsstrahlung in the inner layers, stays at 0.28 of aluminum.
- Read the proton column. At equal mass per area the three single materials stop protons differently: hydrogen-rich polyethylene stops more per gram, tantalum less. The differences are tens of percent, not factors, because the protons that matter at these depths are above several tens of MeV.
Result. Equal mass is not equal shielding, and the ranking changes with depth and with the population that dominates. On this orbit at 1 g/cm², where electrons still dominate, a graded or high-Z wall roughly halves the dose; at 3 g/cm², where protons dominate, the choice of material matters much less and tantalum alone is worse than aluminum. The calculator above gives the same tables for the other orbits. The statistical uncertainty of the Monte Carlo ratios is about 20 % up to 1 g/cm² and about 50 % beyond 1.5 g/cm², which the site states with the figures.
Exercise
Set up a high-Z versus low-Z comparison that means something: for a stated spectrum, a stated endpoint and a stated mass or volume constraint.
Say which constraint the comparison holds fixed, and keep the actual materials in the model when the trade could change the design.
Going deeper
Coupled transport and local dose
The field at the target includes the secondaries the code is able to produce and the effects of material interfaces. In a small scoring volume, the usual bulk-dose assumptions can break down. Charged-particle stopping, electron-photon coupling and nuclear reactions each need physics models and data that are valid at the energies and in the materials involved.
Electron-photon coupling. Bremsstrahlung, scattering, photon interactions and the transport of secondary electrons move energy around inside the shield. At a high-Z interface the local electron fluence and dose can change. Uncollided photon attenuation, as tabulated in XCOM, does not by itself give the absorbed dose or the buildup.
Hadronic field. As protons and ions slow down, their energy and LET change, and nuclear reactions along the way create recoils, fragments, neutrons and other secondaries. Adding material changes the make-up of the field that drives SEE. It does not guarantee that every response moves in the same direction as more material is added.
Scoring scale. State the dimensions of the scoring volume, its material and what surrounds it. When particles escape the volume, or charged-particle equilibrium does not hold, a bulk conversion coefficient may not stand in for a local energy-deposition calculation.
Neutral particles and crew dose. Neutron moderation, scattering, capture and the photons that capture produces all need suitable nuclear data and geometry. Crew equivalent-dose plots apply biological weighting factors and a body geometry. Their numbers cannot be reused as absorbed dose in electronics.
Before and after a defined shield. A simple calculation that follows primary protons through an aluminum path with a restricted Bethe energy-loss formula shows how the spectrum is redistributed. Its source energy window, its 10 MeV output floor and its omission of nuclear and secondary physics have to be stated with it. The result is a changed spectrum, and a changed spectrum cannot be reduced to one scalar shielding factor. Heavy-ion LET behind the shield comes from separate, documented post-shielding tables.
Takeaway
Judge a shield by the radiation that remains at the part and the effect that radiation has on the hardware.
Check yourself
Two shields have the same areal density, one aluminum and one tantalum. Why can the dose behind them differ?
The interactions differ. For electrons, the heavier material produces more bremsstrahlung, which penetrates; for protons the range per gram is similar but the secondary production differs; for low-energy photons, dose enhancement near the heavy material raises the local dose. Equal mass per area is only the starting point.
What does a graded shield change compared with the same mass of a single material?
The order of the layers controls where secondaries are produced and whether they are absorbed before the part: a low-atomic-number layer inside a heavy one absorbs the heavy layer's secondary electrons and photons. The benefit depends on the spectrum and generally has to be computed, not assumed.
In the worked example, a tantalum wall at 1 g/cm² gives about 0.27 of the aluminum electron dose. A designer carries that ratio over to a 3 g/cm² wall. What does the table show?
At 3 g/cm² only bremsstrahlung is left of the electron dose, and tantalum is 1.4 times aluminum: it generates more X rays than it absorbs. The graded aluminum-tantalum-aluminum stack, which absorbs its own bremsstrahlung in the inner layers, stays at 0.28 of aluminum. The ranking changes with depth and with the population that dominates, so a material ratio read at one depth generally cannot be carried to another, and the Monte Carlo ratios themselves carry about 20 % statistical uncertainty up to 1 g/cm² and about 50 % beyond 1.5 g/cm².
A colleague proposes a few millimeters more aluminum on the box to lower both the trapped-proton dose of a part and its heavy-ion SEE rate. Which of the two will it generally help, and why?
The proton dose, generally yes: a 10 MeV proton stops in about 0.17 g/cm² of aluminum (0.6 mm), so a few millimeters remove the low-energy part of the trapped and solar proton spectra and lower the dose and displacement damage, although the spectrum above 100 MeV passes through any practical box and nuclear reactions in the shield add secondaries. The heavy-ion rate, generally no: galactic cosmic rays near 1 GeV per nucleon have ranges of tens of centimeters in aluminum, and the integral flux above the iron knee generally stays within a factor of a few of its free-space value for any realistic thickness. A practical amount of shielding cannot take the place of suitable parts and system mitigation.
Two candidate walls are compared at the same thickness, 1 mm of tantalum against 1 mm of aluminum, and tantalum gives the lower dose. Why is that comparison incomplete?
One mm and one g/cm² are different constraints, one on volume and one on mass, and at equal thickness the dense high-Z wall carries far more areal mass on every ray, so it wins on mass it was not charged for. Compare candidates at equal thickness and at equal mass as two separate comparisons, and say which constraint the design holds fixed. Under a mass limit, low-Z and hydrogen-rich materials can be attractive for protons (in the worked example, polyethylene stops more per gram than aluminum and tantalum less), and which material is better also depends on the incident spectrum, the order of the layers and the quantity scored at the target.
Further reading
- Seltzer (1994): SHIELDOSE-2
- Geant4: electron bremsstrahlung
- Jun et al. (2020): transport-code intercomparison
- Hugh Evans: space environment and calculation methods
- NIST STAR: aluminum composition and density
- NIST STAR: copper composition and density
- NIST STAR: polyethylene composition and density
- Leif Scheick: environment and shielding course, slides 1–19
- Allan Johnston: Space Radiation Effects on Microelectronics, slides 4–29 (environment and ionization) and 19–20 (MER)
- NIST XCOM: photon cross sections
- Geant4: neutron shielding physics
- Geant4: radiative neutron capture
- IEEE NSREC 2018 Short Course, "Variability in Environments, Devices and Radiation Effects", §B
- Slaba and Whitman: BON2020
- ESA/SPENVIS: GCR models and implementations
- IEEE NSREC 2015 Short Course, "Practical Problems in Spacecraft Design", §2
- IEEE NSREC 2022 Short Course, "Multi-Scale, Multi-Physics of Radiation Effects", §3
- ESA/SPENVIS: SHIELDOSE-2 and SHIELDOSE-2Q
- Vanderbilt: CREME96 workflow
- IEEE NSREC 2013 Short Course, "Evolution of Radiation Studies on the Path of Moore’s Law", §4
- IEEE NSREC 2024 Short Course, "Electronic and Photonic Technologies, Basic Concepts to Advanced Mechanisms", §3–4, especially displacement-damage discussion pp
- SR-NIEL: spectral-fluence damage calculation
- NIST STAR: tantalum composition and density
- NIST: ESTAR, PSTAR and ASTAR
- ESA/SPENVIS: layered-shield optimization
- IEEE NSREC 2014 Short Course, "Radiation Environments from Space to Ground", §4
- IEEE NSREC 2016 Short Course, "Techniques for SEE Modeling and Mitigation", §2
- Fetzer et al. (2024): GRAS layered-shield optimization
- ESA/SPENVIS: MULASSIS
- NASA RHA Guidelines: transport and CAD review, Section 4, printed pp
- Koontz (2017): Space Radiation Environments, NASA NESC, slide deck reviewed: slides 4–6 (units, shielding and counting), 10 (July 2000 event), 12–14 (GCR), 29 (cycle and neutron proxy), 31–32 (acc
- Particle Data Group: aluminum material properties
- Bourdarie and Xapsos (2008): The Space Radiation Environment, Sections II–V: solar cycle, GCR, SEP statistics and trapped-particle dynamics
- SILSO / Royal Observatory of Belgium: annual sunspot number V2